What the schools say
| School | Qurbani on behalf of the deceased |
|---|---|
| Hanafi | Allowed, and the reward reaches the deceased |
| Hanbali | Allowed and rewarded |
| Shafi'i | Not valid unless the deceased left a bequest (wasiyyah) for it |
| Maliki | Disliked (makruh), though the reward of charity still reaches |
The evidence
The Prophet ﷺ sacrificed a ram and said: “In the name of Allah. O Allah, accept from Muhammad, the family of Muhammad and the ummah of Muhammad” (Sahih Muslim 1967). His ummah included people who had died, and scholars who allow it cite this. A narration that ‘Ali sacrificed every year on the Prophet's ﷺ behalf is in Sunan Abi Dawud (2790), though its chain is weak.
More generally, authentic hadith confirm that charity given for a deceased person benefits them; see Sadaqah for the deceased.
Who eats the meat?
If the Qurbani is a voluntary gift of reward to the deceased, the family may eat, gift and give the meat as with any Qurbani. If it fulfils the deceased's bequest, the Hanafi school holds that all of it should go to the poor.
Your own Qurbani comes first
If Qurbani is due on you (see the Qurbani rules), give your own first. A Qurbani for a parent is an additional act. Some families give one goat for themselves and one for a late parent.
An option all scholars accept
Sacrificing a goat as Sadaqah in the deceased's name, any day of the year, with the meat given to the poor, is accepted by all schools. Our Sadaqah service does exactly this. For Eid al-Adha, our Qurbani service can carry out a Qurbani in a loved one's name if you follow a view that allows it.
References
- Sahih Muslim 1967: the Prophet's ﷺ sacrifice for his family and ummah.
- Sunan Abi Dawud 2790: narration of ‘Ali (weak chain).
- Comparative positions: Radd al-Muhtar (Hanafi); al-Nawawi, al-Majmu' (Shafi'i); Ibn Qudamah, al-Mughni (Hanbali).