Why people ask
In Bangladesh, families often share a cow for Qurbani at Eid al-Adha. When a child is born near Eid, or an older child's Aqiqah is still due, many ask whether a share in the Qurbani cow can count as the Aqiqah. Others ask whether one goat can serve both purposes.
Taking an Aqiqah share in a cow
A cow or camel can be shared by up to seven people for Qurbani. The question is whether some of those seven shares can be for Aqiqah instead:
| School | Aqiqah share in a cow |
|---|---|
| Hanafi | Allowed: shares for Qurbani and Aqiqah can be combined, as each is an act of worship |
| Shafi'i | Allowed: each seventh counts for its own intention |
| Hanbali | Many prefer a whole animal for Aqiqah; some allow shares |
| Maliki | Shares are not used for Aqiqah: one whole animal per child |
For a boy, those who allow shares count two shares as the equivalent of two goats.
Can one goat count as both?
A goat counts for one person's Qurbani, or one Aqiqah. Most scholars hold that one goat cannot fulfil both, because each is a separate act of worship with its own intention. A view is reported from Imam Ahmad and some scholars that if an Aqiqah falls on the days of Eid, one sacrifice may suffice for both, but it is a minority position.
The simplest option
If you want to be safe according to every school, give separate animals: your Qurbani, and the Aqiqah goats (two for a boy, one for a girl). Our service is goat-based, so each Aqiqah and each Qurbani is a separate goat. If you follow a view allowing shares, ask your local scholar.
For the full Qurbani rules see the Qurbani rules guide; for Aqiqah see Aqiqah rules.
References
- Shared sacrifice in cattle and camels: Sahih Muslim 1318 (seven people per animal).
- Comparative positions: Ibn Qudamah, al-Mughni; al-Nawawi, al-Majmu'; Hanafi works such as Radd al-Muhtar.